Understanding the Impact of GST on India’s Digital Economy

1. Statutory Framework: Governing E-commerce Taxation in India

The taxation of e-commerce transactions in India is governed by a multi-faceted statutory framework comprising direct and indirect tax laws. This framework ensures that e-commerce operators and participants comply with their tax obligations.

1.1 Income Tax Act, 1961 (ITA) and Relevant Amendments

The Income Tax Act, 1961, forms the backbone of direct taxation in India. It encompasses provisions for taxing various income sources, including those arising from e-commerce activities. A crucial aspect of this act related to e-commerce is the tax deduction at source (TDS) mechanism.

• Section 194-O: TDS on E-commerce Transactions: Section 194-O, introduced to broaden the tax base, mandates e-commerce operators to deduct tax at 1% on the gross amount of sales or services facilitated through their digital platform. This deduction applies at the earlier of when the amount is credited to the e-commerce participant’s account or when payment is made.
• Scope and Applicability: This section applies to e-commerce operators facilitating the sale of goods or provision of services. It aims to capture transactions that might have previously escaped the tax net. The “e-commerce operator” is defined as a person who owns, operates, or manages a digital or electronic facility or platform for electronic commerce.
• Exemptions and Thresholds: There are certain exemptions and thresholds under Section 194-O. For instance, no deduction is required if the gross amount of sales or services during the financial year does not exceed ₹5 lakhs, and the e-commerce participant furnishes their PAN/Aadhaar.
• CBDT Circular No. 20/2023: The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) issued Circular No. 20/2023 on December 28, 2023, to clarify the applicability of Section 194-O in multiple e-commerce operator models, such as the Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC). These circular addresses difficulties and provides clarity through FAQs, detailing various scenarios with examples. It specifically addresses scenarios such as:

-When an e-commerce operator is also an e-commerce participant

– How the TDS applies when there is multiple e-commerce operators involved in a single transaction.

• Finance Act, 2020: The Finance Act, 2020, introduced Section 194-O to ensure that e-commerce operators deduct/withhold tax at 1% on the gross amount from sales of goods or services facilitated through their digital platform. The legislative intent was to widen the tax base and bring e-commerce transactions under the tax ambit.

1.2 Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST)

The Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017, is a key component of India’s indirect tax regime. It governs the levy and collection of GST on intra-state supplies of goods and services. For e-commerce, Section 52 of the CGST Act is particularly relevant.

• Section 52: TCS Obligations for E-commerce Operators: Section 52 mandates that e-commerce operators collect tax at source (TCS) on the net value of taxable supplies made through their platform. The collected tax is then deposited with the government.
• Rate of TCS: The rate of TCS under the CGST Act is typically 0.5% on the net value of taxable supplies. When combined with the State Goods and Services Tax (SGST), the total TCS rate becomes 1%.
• Compliance Requirements: E-commerce operators are required to furnish monthly statements detailing the supplies made through their platforms and the TCS collected. They must also provide an annual statement reconciling the monthly data.
• Impact on Small Suppliers: The TCS provision impacts small suppliers who use e-commerce platforms to sell their goods. The TCS amount is available as credit to the suppliers, which they can use to offset their GST liability.

1.3 Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (IGST)

The Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) Act, 2017, governs the taxation of inter-state supplies of goods and services. It ensures that transactions between states are taxed appropriately.

• Place of Supply Rules: Determining the place of supply is crucial for IGST. The IGST Act provides detailed rules to ascertain where a supply is deemed to have been made. For e-commerce, these rules consider the location of the supplier, the recipient, and the destination of the goods.
• Ensuring Tax Allocation: The IGST mechanism ensures that the tax revenue is allocated to the state where the goods or services are ultimately consumed. This prevents disputes and promotes a unified tax system.
• E-commerce Transactions: For e-commerce, the place of supply rules is particularly relevant when goods are shipped from one state to a customer in another state. The IGST is levied, and the revenue is allocated to the destination state.

1.4 Equalization Levy (Introduced by the Finance Act, 2016 and expanded in subsequent Finance Acts)

The Equalization Levy was introduced to tax the digital economy, especially non-resident e-commerce operators providing services in India without a permanent establishment.

• Finance Act, 2016: The Finance Act, 2016, initially introduced the Equalization Levy, targeting online advertising services provided by non-residents.
• Finance Act, 2020: Expansion of Scope: The Finance Act, 2020, expanded the scope of the Equalization Levy to include a 2% tax on e-commerce supply or services provided by non-residents without a permanent establishment in India. This levy applies to online sales of goods or provision of services to Indian residents.
• Objective: The primary objective of the Equalization Levy is to ensure that foreign digital companies contributing to the Indian economy pay taxes, even without a physical presence. This measure aims to level the playing field between domestic and foreign e-commerce operators.
• Challenges and Considerations: The Equalization Levy has faced criticism from some countries and international organizations. Concerns have been raised about its compatibility with international tax treaties and its potential impact on cross-border trade.

2. Tax Deduction at Source for E-Commerce Transactions

2.1 Section 194-O of the Income Tax Act

• Applicability: Section 194-O of the Income Tax Act, introduced through the Finance Act 2020, mandates that e-commerce operators deduct tax at source (TDS) at a rate of 1% on the gross amount of sales or services facilitated through their digital or electronic platforms. This provision aims to broaden the tax base by imposing withholding tax obligations on e-commerce platforms, enabling the government to collect tax at the point of transaction.

This became effective on October 1, 2020. The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has issued guidelines to address difficulties and provide clarity on the applicability of Section 194-O, especially in multiple e-commerce operator models like the Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC). These guidelines clarify how TDS obligations are to be met when there is multiple e-commerce operators involved in a single transaction.

To ensure compliance, e-commerce operators must obtain the Permanent Account Number (PAN) of the e-commerce participants. The TDS should be deposited with the government within the prescribed timelines, typically within seven days from the end of the month in which the deduction is made, using the challan-cum-statement Form 26Q. The e-commerce operator must also furnish a TDS certificate (Form 16A) to the e-commerce participant, providing details of the TDS deducted and deposited.

• Threshold: Section 194-O is triggered if the gross number of sales, services, or both exceeds INR 5 lakh annually for resident individuals or Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs). This threshold ensures that small-scale e-commerce participants are not burdened with TDS compliance.

If an e-commerce participant fails to provide their KYC documents, including a PAN card and Aadhaar card, the TDS deduction rate is 5%, irrespective of the gross amount. This higher rate incentivizes participants to comply with KYC norms. The TDS must be deducted at the time of crediting the seller’s account or at the time of payment, whichever is earlier, irrespective of the mode of payment.

• Exemptions: No TDS is applicable under Section 194-O if the e-commerce participant is a non-resident. However, it is crucial to note that other provisions, such as the Equalisation Levy, might still apply to the non-resident e-commerce participants. The exemption under Section 194-O is specifically for the TDS requirement and doesn’t provide blanket relief from all other tax obligations.

2.2 Non-Resident E-Commerce Participants

Non-residents supplying goods or services through digital platforms may be subject to Equalization Levy, which is typically 2% or 6% based on the nature of the transaction. The 2% levy applies to consideration received or receivable by an e-commerce operator from online sale of goods or provision of services to Indian residents or those using an Indian IP address. The 6% levy applies to online advertisement services.

Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) benefits may be explored to ensure compliance with international tax treaties, subject to specific conditions. India has entered into DTAAs with several countries to avoid double taxation and provide relief to taxpayers. Under these agreements, a non-resident may claim treaty benefits, such as reduced tax rates or exemption from tax, provided they meet the conditions specified in the DTAA. To claim DTAA benefits, the non-resident must provide a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) issued by the tax authorities of their country of residence.

Non-residents should also be aware of the concept of a Permanent Establishment (PE) in India. If a non-resident e-commerce entity has a PE in India, its profits attributable to the PE would be taxable in India as per the Income Tax Act, 1961. A PE could include a fixed place of business, such as an office, a branch, or a place of management. The determination of whether a non-resident has a PE in India is based on the specific facts and circumstances of each case and relevant provisions of the applicable DTAA.

3. GST Obligations for E-Commerce

E-commerce operations in India are governed by stringent provisions under the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017 and the Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) Act, 2017. The following sections expand on compulsory registration criteria, obligations related to the place of supply, mandates on e-invoicing, and guidelines for Tax Collection at Source (TCS) as per current legal requirements. These aspects collectively form the framework within which e-commerce entities must function to fulfill their duties under Indian law.

3.1 Mandatory Registration and Compliance

The CGST Act, particularly Section 24, requires e-commerce operators to register irrespective of their turnover. This rule ensures that online platforms, which enable multiple sellers to reach a wide consumer base, remain accountable for tax collection and reporting obligations. Since no threshold relaxation applies, platforms handling even minimal transactions must still comply with registration guidelines.

Under Section 52 of the CGST Act, operators are responsible for collecting tax at source at a prescribed rate of 1% when making payments to sellers. This mechanism ensures that revenue authorities receive a preliminary portion of taxes before the final GST settlement. E-commerce operators must verify that they have the appropriate registration certificates and maintain precise records of seller transactions. Failure to do so could lead to penalties under Section 122 of the CGST Act and expose operators to interest and late fees under Sections 50 and 47 for delayed payments or filings.

3.2 Place of Supply Rules

Under the IGST Act, it is necessary to determine whether a supply is intra-state or inter-state to levy the correct type of GST. The place of supply provisions are critical, as they directly decide whether the transaction will attract Central GST (CGST) and State GST (SGST) or Integrated GST (IGST).

In cases involving goods, the relevant rule often focuses on the destination where the goods are delivered to the recipient. If this destination lies in a different state than the supplier’s location, the supply is treated as inter-state, leading to IGST applicability. Conversely, if both the supplier’s location and place of delivery lie in the same state, CGST and SGST become applicable. Services are governed by Sections 12 and 13 of the IGST Act, where the nature of the service and the recipient’s location typically determine whether CGST + SGST or IGST will be charged.

Maintaining updated tax rate details for each product category or service offering is essential, as the government periodically revises rates through notifications. E-commerce platforms must incorporate adequate compliance checks to ensure the correct classification of products and services and the corresponding rate of tax.

3.3 E-Invoicing Mandates

E-invoicing rules under the GST framework were introduced to enhance transparency and streamline the invoicing process. Presently, this system applies to businesses that have an aggregate turnover above INR 5 crore in any financial year. Recent amendments by the GST Council lowered the threshold from previously higher limits, which means more businesses, including those operating through e-commerce platforms, now fall under e-invoicing requirements.

Under these rules, every invoice above the threshold turnover limit must be registered on the Invoice Registration Portal (IRP), where an Invoice Reference Number (IRN) and a Quick Response (QR) Code are generated. Section 31 of the CGST Act governs the issuance of invoices, and e-commerce operators must confirm that sellers using their platform comply with these regulations. Although operators themselves may not be required to issue e-invoices on behalf of sellers, they are advised to establish robust processes to track compliance. Proper record-keeping is also mandated under Sections 35 and 36 of the CGST Act, as authorities may conduct audits to ensure that all invoices are duly registered, and taxes are appropriately collected.

3.4 Tax Collection at Source (TCS)

The obligation to collect TCS arises from Section 52 of the CGST Act, under which e-commerce operators must withhold 1% of the net taxable value when making payments to their sellers. This system provides revenue authorities with a preliminary deposit of the tax portion, enhancing the overall compliance environment in the e-commerce sector.

Collected amounts must be deposited with the government by the 10th of the subsequent month. E-commerce operators must file the TCS return in Form GSTR-8 every month to declare these collections. An annual statement capturing the total TCS for the financial year also needs to be submitted, reinforcing accountability and transparency across the platform’s operations. Any delay in depositing TCS may attract interest under Section 50, and incorrect or late filing can result in liabilities as prescribed under Section 47 of the CGST Act.

Operators are encouraged to keep an updated schedule of TCS filings and integrate reliable accounting software to track collections in real time. Given that authorities expect timely compliance, regular internal reviews of all TCS records can mitigate potential disputes and help avoid interest or penalties.

4. Equalization Levy on Digital Transactions

The Indian government has implemented the Equalization Levy to tax digital transactions involving non-resident entities. This levy is aimed at ensuring that foreign digital companies contributing to the Indian economy through online advertising and e-commerce activities pay taxes in India.

4.1 6% Equalization Levy on Specified Services

Origin and Legal Basis

• Finance Act, 2016: This act introduced the initial framework for the Equalization Levy, specifically targeting digital advertising services.
• Objective: The primary aim was to tax income accruing to foreign companies from online advertisement services provided in India, where these companies have a significant economic presence but may not have a physical presence that would trigger traditional corporate tax obligations.

Scope and Applicability

• Covered Services: The levy applies to consideration received by non-resident entities for providing specified services, primarily online advertising, digital advertising space, and related facilities.
• Taxable Transactions: Any payment made to a non-resident entity for online advertising services, where the aggregate amount of consideration exceeds INR 1 lakh in a financial year, is subject to this levy.
• Payer’s Responsibility: The entity making the payment (the payer), whether an Indian resident or a non-resident with a permanent establishment in India, is responsible for deducting and depositing the levy with the government.

Compliance Requirements

• Deduction and Payment: The payer must deduct the 6% levy at the time of payment to the non-resident entity.
• Deposit Timeline: The deducted amount must be deposited with the Indian government by the 7th of the following month in which the deduction was made.
• Reporting: The payer is required to furnish details of the payment and the levy deducted in specified forms as prescribed by the Income Tax Department.

4.2 2% Equalization Levy on E-Commerce Operators

Expansion of Scope: Finance Act, 2020

• Effective Date: This levy came into effect on April 1, 2020, broadening the scope of the Equalization Levy to include e-commerce transactions.
• Rationale: The expansion was intended to capture the revenue generated by non-resident e-commerce operators from transactions with Indian customers, leveling the playing field between domestic and foreign digital businesses.

Scope and Applicability

• E-Commerce Operator Definition: An e-commerce operator is defined as a non-resident entity that owns, operates, or manages a digital or electronic facility or platform for online sales of goods or provision of services.
• Taxable Transactions: The levy applies to the consideration received by the e-commerce operator from:

– Online sale of goods to an Indian resident.

– Online provision of services to an Indian resident.

– Sale of goods or provision of services to a non-resident, where the goods or services are used in India.

• Threshold: The 2% levy applies if the e-commerce operator’s revenue from such supplies exceeds INR 2 crore during the financial year.

Compliance Requirements

• Quarterly Payment: E-commerce operators are required to pay the 2% levy on a quarterly basis.
• Annual Statement : Non-resident e-commerce operators must file an annual statement in Form No. 1, providing details of the consideration received and the levy paid. The due date for filing this statement is June 30 of the subsequent financial year.
• Penalties: Failure to comply with the payment and reporting requirements can result in penalties under the Income Tax Act, 1961.

4.3 Compliance and Reporting: A Consolidated View

To ensure adherence to the Equalization Levy provisions, non-resident entities and Indian payers must fulfill the following key compliance requirements:

• Payment Timeline: The levy must be paid on a quarterly basis, with specific due dates for each quarter.
• Form No. 1: Non-resident operators must file an annual statement in Form No. 1, providing detailed information on the transactions and the levy paid.
• Due Date: The annual statement must be filed by June 30 of the subsequent financial year.
• Penalties for Non-Compliance:

– Late Payment: Interest is charged on late payments of the Equalization Levy.

– Failure to Deduct/Collect: Penalties may be imposed for failure to deduct or collect the levy.

– Incorrect Reporting: Penalties can be levied for furnishing inaccurate or incomplete information in the annual statement.

5. Recent Amendments and Updates in Indian E-commerce Regulations

5.1 Finance Act, 2023: Impact on TDS and Digital Transactions

The Finance Act, 2023, has brought about significant changes impacting tax deductions at source (TDS) and compliance for e-commerce entities. These changes are designed to refine the existing tax framework and ensure better compliance across digital platforms.

Refined TDS Thresholds and Compliance Requirements

• Impact: The Act has fine-tuned the TDS thresholds, necessitating e-commerce businesses to closely monitor their transactions to ensure accurate and timely deductions. This refinement directly impacts the cash flow management and reporting obligations of these entities.
• Legal Basis: The amendments relate to various sections, including Section 194J (fees for professional or technical services), Section 194H (commission or brokerage), and Section 194C (payments to contractors), where TDS thresholds have been revised. The specific threshold amounts are detailed in the Act and related circulars issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT).

Expanded Scope of Section 194-O: Enhancing Tax Compliance on Digital Platforms

• Impact: Section 194-O, which mandates TDS on e-commerce transactions, has been broadened to encompass a wider range of digital platforms. This expansion ensures that more transactions fall under the tax radar, improving overall compliance.
• Legal Basis: The expansion involves clarifying the definition of “e-commerce participant” and “e-commerce operator” under Section 194-O of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Amendments ensure that all entities facilitating sales through digital or electronic facilities or platforms are covered.

5.2 GST Council Updates: TCS Obligations and E-Invoicing Thresholds

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) Council has introduced key updates affecting tax collection at source (TCS) and e-invoicing, which are critical for e-commerce operations.

Clarifications on TCS Obligations for E-commerce Operators

• Impact: The GST Council has provided clarifications on TCS obligations for e-commerce operators, ensuring that these entities correctly collect and remit taxes on behalf of their suppliers. Increased enforcement is aimed at ensuring timely GST payments.
• Legal Basis: Under Section 52 of the CGST Act, 2017, e-commerce operators are required to collect TCS at a specified rate (usually 1%) on the net value of taxable supplies made through their platform. Clarifications address issues such as the treatment of returns, cancellations, and the scope of “supplies” subject to TCS.

Lowered E-Invoicing Threshold: Broadening the Compliance Base

• Impact: The e-invoicing threshold has been reduced to INR 5 crore, expanding the base of businesses required to generate invoices electronically. This move is aimed at improving transparency, reducing tax evasion, and streamlining the invoicing process.
• Legal Basis: Rule 48(4) of the CGST Rules, 2017, specifies the class of persons required to issue e-invoices. Notifications issued periodically by the CBIC lower the threshold based on aggregate turnover in previous financial years.

5.3 Compliance Enhancements: Integrating Payment Gateways and Data Analytics

Recent compliance enhancements focus on integrating payment gateways with GST reporting and increasing data analytics-based scrutiny to address revenue leakages.

Integration of Payment Gateways with GST Reporting

• Impact: E-commerce entities are now mandated to integrate their payment gateways with GST reporting systems. This integration helps minimize discrepancies between reported sales and actual transactions, ensuring more accurate tax reporting.
• Legal Basis: This requirement is facilitated through amendments to the GST Rules, which mandate the submission of payment gateway data along with GST returns (GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B). These rules enable tax authorities to cross-verify transaction data and identify potential discrepancies.

Increased Data Analytics-Based Scrutiny

• Impact: Government authorities are leveraging data analytics to scrutinize e-commerce transactions and identify potential revenue leakages. This includes analyzing transaction patterns, identifying discrepancies, and detecting fraudulent activities.
• Legal Basis: This scrutiny is supported by Section 66 of the CGST Act, 2017, which empowers tax authorities to conduct audits and investigations based on data analysis and risk assessment. The use of data analytics tools helps in identifying cases warranting further investigation and enforcement action.

Conclusion

Taxation on digital transactions and e-commerce in India is governed by multiple legal provisions under the Income Tax Act, the GST Acts, and the Equalization Levy. Section 194-O of the Income Tax Act obligates e-commerce operators to deduct TDS on qualifying transactions, while Sections 9(5) of the CGST Act and Section 52 address GST collection and compliance requirements. The Equalization Levy imposes obligations on non-resident operators supplying digital services or conducting e-commerce transactions in India.

These provisions are enforced by regular updates in the Finance Acts and notifications by the GST Council. E-commerce operators and participants must establish robust systems to meet TDS, TCS, and equalization levy requirements while maintaining accurate transaction records. Failure to comply can result in penalties, making it essential for platforms and sellers to ensure full adherence to Indian tax laws under the most recent legislative amendments.

Click here to explore and learn more about the various Practice Areas offered by Agrud Partners.